Our customers rate us 5.0 out of 5on Google

Open 24 hours, 7 days a week

Roofing Blog

8 Roof Problems on Matthews, NC Homes and What Fixes Them

Older subdivisions, second-layer roofs and a lot of shade. These are the problems we find on Matthews houses, where to look for each one, and what fixes it.

Charcoal shingle roof we finished on a brick ranch home in Matthews, NC, seen by drone
A finished re-roof on a brick ranch in Matthews.

The short answer

Most roof problems on Matthews, NC homes come from age and shade. These subdivisions are older than the ones in Weddington and Waxhaw, many roofs are on their second shingle, and big trees keep the north slopes damp. A failed detail on a roof with years left gets repaired. Wear across whole slopes means a new roof.

Charlotte Premier Roofing does this work on houses across town, and the list below comes from what we keep on our page about the roofs we work on in Matthews. If you are still choosing a company, our list for roofing Matthews NC ranks the local roofers holding a 5.0 rating by how many people reviewed them.

ProblemWhere it showsUsual fix
Second shingle layerThick drip edge, lumpy slopesTear-off to the deck
Nail popsSmall bumps or lifted tabsRepair, unless they run across the slope
Unseen deckingSoft spots underfootReplace soft sheets at tear-off
Split pipe bootStain below a plumbing ventNew boot
Rusted flue or chimney flashingStain near the flue or chimneyNew flashing
Moss, algae, leaf loadNorth slopes and valleysCareful cleaning, trimming
Limb or wind damageCreased or missing shinglesTarp if open, repair, maybe a claim
Mismatched ventingHot attic after a re-roofRidge vent and clear soffits

1. A second layer of shingles over the first

A lot of Matthews roofs are on their second shingle or overdue for it, and some of those second roofs were laid right over the first. North Carolina’s residential code sets the limit here: a roof that already has two or more applications of roof covering cannot take another one on top. So when that second layer wears out, the only way forward is off.

You can often spot it from the ground at the eave, where the shingle edge looks thick. Old paperwork from the last re-roof or home sale may tell you too. We take the roof to the decking on every replacement, and our page on roof replacement in Matthews, NC covers the order of work.

2. Nail pops through the older layer

A nail that backs out pushes up the shingle above it. On a layered roof the nails holding the top shingles have to go through an old layer before they reach wood, and on these houses we find them working loose. From the yard a nail pop looks like a small bump or a tab that will not lie flat.

One or two are a repair. The spot gets sealed and the shingle goes back down or gets replaced. One reviewer, Sebastian B., wrote that our crew did “a great job of replacing my wind damaged shingles and sealing any exposed nails they found on my roof.” If we find them across a whole slope, the conversation changes, and we will show you the photos.

3. Decking nobody has seen since the first re-roof

When a second roof went on over the first, nobody looked at the wood underneath. On some Matthews houses that decking has not been seen in decades, and it is the item a quote cannot fully price until the old roof is off.

From inside, check the attic on a bright day for daylight or dark staining along the sheathing. On the roof, our owner feels for soft spots as he walks it. Any sheet that is soft gets replaced at tear-off, and the deck is photographed before the underlayment goes on. It is also why one of our questions to ask a roofing contractor in Matthews deals with how a quote handles decking.

4. Split pipe boots

The rubber collar around a plumbing vent is one of the first things to give out, because the sun cracks it long before the shingles around it are done. It is a common source of a leak on a roof that otherwise has life left, and a ceiling stain below a bathroom is a typical clue. A split boot is a small job when it gets caught early, and it is a good reason not to assume a stain means a new roof.

5. Rusted flue and chimney flashing

Metal around a furnace flue or a chimney ages on its own schedule. On the older subdivisions near the center of town we see rusted flue flashing and tired chimney flashing on roofs where the shingles still have years in them. If a stain sits near one of those penetrations, or shows up only in certain storms, look there first.

The fix is new flashing, and on a re-roof it should be new anyway. On our repair calls flashing is usually where a roof goes first, so ask about reused flashing on any quote.

6. Moss, algae and leaves on the shaded slopes

The center of Matthews sits on a ridge that drains north to McAlpine Creek and south to Fourmile Creek, and the older neighborhoods there have real slopes and mature trees. That shade keeps moss and algae going on north slopes, and leaves pile up in the valleys.

The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association says there is no scientific evidence that algae damages asphalt shingles, though it does change how a roof looks. Moss is different. It can lift or curl the leading edges of shingles, which raises the risk of blow-off in wind. The association also says never to use a pressure washer on a shingle roof, because it causes granule loss. Keep branches trimmed back and debris off the roof. If you hire out the cleaning, make sure no pressure washer comes along.

7. Limbs after an ice storm and shingles lifted by wind

After an ice storm, a limb on a Matthews roof is the thing we photograph most. Wind does its own version on these houses, creasing or lifting shingles along the edges and ridges. When water is coming in, an emergency tarp goes up first and the repair gets scheduled after.

Take pictures from the ground before anything moves, and stay off an icy roof. We photograph each hit for your adjuster if it is going to be a claim. Our guide on roof repair explains how we find the source of the water, because the stain inside often sits a long way from the damage on top.

8. Venting that suited the old roof

Some of these houses still have venting that suited a three-tab roof and does not suit an architectural one. When a roof gets replaced, the attic gets looked at too: we check for a ridge vent and clear soffit intake, and we mention it if the existing setup falls short. You may never see this one from the yard. An attic check is the only way to know, and it is part of our free inspection.

When is it a repair, and when is it a new roof?

A single failed detail on a roof with years left is a repair. That covers most of items 2, 4, 5 and 7. Wear across whole slopes, a soft deck in several places, or a leak that keeps coming back after patching is when we would talk about replacement, and if that is your house, an itemized estimate is what lets you compare your options.

Home sales bring many of these up at once. Edwin C. wrote that he “had Matthew come out and repair and seal a couple of roofing tasks I had from my home inspection.” If that is where you are, read our guide to a roof inspection in Matthews before you buy or sell. And if a new roof is already booked, here is how to prepare your Matthews home.

Start with the inspection

We would rather look than guess. Call (704) 352-1112 or request a free roof inspection. Our owner walks the roof and the attic, photographs what he finds, and you get a written estimate with no obligation on it.

Sources. North Carolina Residential Code, Section R908.3.1.1, Roof Recover Not Allowed, read November 5, 2026; Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association, Algae & Moss Prevention and Cleaning for Asphalt Roofing Systems, read November 5, 2026. The two reviews are quoted from our Google profile. What we see on Matthews roofs is as described on our own service pages.

Written by

Charlotte Premier Roofing, owner-run and based in Weddington, NC.

Get Started Today

Ready for a straight answer on your roof?

Call Charlotte Premier Roofing or send the form. Our owner comes out, photographs the roof and the attic, and you get a written estimate with no obligation on it.

Weddington, NC

Call Now: (704) 352-1112